I like the TOS aesthetic. I like that they thought about the functionality of the tools and equipment, even if it's something we see on screen one time. Yes the other shows did this, the work the Okuda's did was good as well, but in TOS it truly looks like a progression from NASA era to a future NASA. ENT also looks like a natural mid point between NASA and TOS. I don't care that TOS has cardboard sets or it looks "outdated", I still like it.
SNW gets some of of the TOS aesthetic right, but it's almost as if they're scared to go full on. They do a good job of mostly making it look good, but their writing is uneven. When you have only 10 episodes, every episode needs to be pretty good and not gimmicky.